In our test, the Allen set from asaki one for Torx screws good Leave an impression. The product provides a full set of Torx keys in high quality at a relatively low price. The keys fit perfectly in torx screws. High torques can be applied with the long handle. It is also positive that no signs of use can be seen even after the test. Also one holder pocket with practical sorting is part of the set. Nevertheless, a better fit of the keys in the holder pocket, as well as packaging with contact information appropriate to the product would have been desirable.
Benefits
✅ High stability of the keys
✅ Long handle for high torque
✅ Security Torx
✅ No noticeable wear and tear
Disadvantages
❌ unfavorable packaging
❌ Contact information incomplete
❌ Poor fit of the keys in the holder
The test
General Information
We got the article in the practical test examined and tested in detail. Below we go into more detail about the features and impressions. The product, from the packaging to the materials and quality to the range of functions and handling our test procedure subjected.
To give you a quick overview, we work with a points system. The maximum possible number of points per area is 100 points. The final overall grade is calculated from the average of all tested characteristics, taking into account the respective weightings. For a detailed insight into our comprehensive Evaluation process, which forms the basis of all our product reviews, please click here.
The first impression
The packaging and markings
ℹ️ Here we take a closer look at the packaging. Sustainability is becoming an increasingly important factor. In addition, of course, adequate protection of the product must also be ensured.
Criterion | Remark | Points scored* |
---|---|---|
product protection | Product protection given at all times despite damaged packaging | 95 points |
sustainability packaging | Blister packaging uses a lot of plastic and cannot be reused | 65 points |
packaging convenience | Tools required to open, sharp edges after cutting open | 55 points |
Total | 72 points |
*The maximum number of points is 100 points
The ASAKI Allen key set came in a typical Amazon mailer at. The mailing bag could be opened easily and without any additional tools thanks to the tear strip. Inside was the set of keys, welded into one Blister. It is a clear, hard plastic packaging with a pouch inside that matches the shape of the product.
The blister had a tear in the upper right corner and a small piece had broken away from the lower right corner. Since the blister pack is very robust and the product itself is not sensitive, it was product protection given in full at all times despite the damage.
From our point of view, a blister would not have been necessary. True, he represents a very safe form of packaging but this is not necessary for the type of product. A simpler and more manageable packaging, for example made of cardboard, would have been perfectly sufficient. Since the blister cannot be opened without destroying it, it cannot be reused. The advantage of the blister is that the key set is completely safe from dirt and scratches.
Tools such as scissors are required to open the blister. The sliced blister turns out to be sharp-edged. Although this is uncomfortable when unpacking, there is no risk of serious injury.
After unpacking
The package contents and instructions
ℹ️ The first impression after unpacking sticks in most people's minds. Are the package contents complete and does the manufacturer make it as easy as possible for me to use the product directly?
Criterion | Remark | Points scored* |
---|---|---|
Package Contents & Scope | Complete set of keys with holder bag | 100 points |
Instructions | Not available, but not absolutely necessary for this product | 90 points |
Contact information | Manufacturer name on back of package, contact information only in Chinese or not available | 45 points |
Total | 78 points |
*The maximum number of points is 100 points
The Allen key set consists of a total of ten parts: Nine Torx key and a hinged holder pocket. The holder pocket consists of a black and an orange plastic part, which are connected via the hinge. The individual keys are located in precisely fitting holes, which means that the keys are sorted by size. Sizes range from T10 to T50. The sizes are stamped next to the holes on the holder pocket.
An Instructions is not included in the set, but not absolutely necessary for such a product. On the back of the packaging there is a simple graphic showing how the keys are used.
Also on the back is the full manufacturer's name, as well as the Contact information. The latter consists of the company address and a telephone number without the associated area code. However, both are only printed in Chinese characters. An email address does not exist.
First time in hand
Product processing and appearance
ℹ️ Before we start the practical test, we take a close look at the product processing. How high-quality are the materials used? Are the haptics & optics satisfactory?
Criterion | Remark | Points scored* |
---|---|---|
Visual Appearance | High quality keys, simple holder pocket | 90 points |
application | Immaculate keys, but fit in holder pocket can be upgraded | 80 points |
stability | Even the smallest key can hardly be bent by hand | 100 points |
sustainability of the product | Material-saving bracket | 100 points |
Total | 93 points |
*The maximum number of points is 100 points
According to the manufacturer, the individual keys are made of hardened chrome vanadium steel and have a long lever. In practice, too, the keys make you very quality impression. Even the smallest key can hardly be bent, a long durability is to be expected. The manufacturer's name ASAKI, CR-V as an abbreviation for chrome vanadium steel and the respective size of the torx are printed on the long side of the key.
With this very high-quality impression, the holder pocket not quite keep up. The plastic doesn't feel quite as valuable as the metal of the keys. While the keys slide easily out of the holder and back in, they aren't held securely in place. If the filled holder bag is turned upside down, some of the keys will fall out. Also, most keys have a light one Game in the holes of the holder pocket. The design of the holder bag from only two relatively small pieces is in line with the Sustainability, since significantly less material is required than for a closed shell.
That was the result of our practical test
Does the manufacturer keep its advertising promises?
ℹ️ Our practical test has the highest relevance and therefore the most weight. Here the product has to undergo a wide variety of criteria and tests. We check the functions and product promises of the test article.
Criterion | Remark | Points scored* |
---|---|---|
Use of the holder pocket | Advantageous sorting, no possibility of direct attachment to the belt | 90 points |
Fast screwing in with the short side | The key sits more securely in the screw, but is limited to low torques due to the low lever | 95 points |
Screw with the long side | Problem-free generation of high torques thanks to the long lever | 95 points |
Use on hexagon socket screws | Works without damaging the key | 100 points |
durability and wear and tear | No signs of wear visible after the test | 100 points |
Total | 96 points |
*The maximum number of points is 100 points
By sorting the keys in the holder pocket Depending on the size, the right key can be found quickly. Also the light weight of the holder bag in mobile applications. Unfortunately, the holder bag lacks a suitable eyelet or comparable device to attach the holder bag to a belt or in a tool case. Unfortunately, the eyelet for hanging the holder bag on typical supermarket shelf hooks is too small.
The keys themselves are excellent to use. The keys fit perfectly into Torx screws and ensure that the torque is securely transmitted to the screw. At the end of the short side is the Security Torx with the associated circular indentation in the middle.
The long side is relatively long at 95 mm (T10) to 220 mm (T50). This can also be done without much effort high torques raise. In practice, however, it is noticeable that the short side of 18 mm (T10) to 45 mm (T50) is somewhat short, especially with the small keys. This forces the user to switch to the long side fairly early on if the short side cannot apply enough torque. When using the long side, however, it is difficult to support the key at the tight, short end. This is particularly necessary if components are to be screwed together without pre-drilling.
Although not specifically meant for that, “abuse” has also been key to classics Allen- Screws checked. These could also be screwed without any problems, even if the key naturally does not sit quite as securely in the screw as in the associated Torx screws.
Overall, all assigned tasks could be completed quickly and reliably with the keys. Even after the test, the keys point no signs of use not even on the edges of the Torx profile. The fear that the anti-rust coating applied by the manufacturer would come loose during use is not confirmed. Accordingly, the key set of ASAKI can be a High quality be certified.
Price-performance ratio
and consumer reviews
ℹ️ Finally, let's talk about how the product compares to the competition. Can it keep up with the competition in terms of price and quality? Would we generally recommend a purchase? We also examine consumer reviews and verify that the critical and positive reviews are actually justified.
Criterion | Remark | Points scored* |
---|---|---|
Price-performance ratio | good price / quality ratio | 90 points |
rating cut | 4,4 out of 5,0 on Amazon | 70 points |
Total | 80 points |
*The maximum number of points is 100 points
On the platform Amazon Consumers give the product an average rating of 4,4 stars given. The quality is often criticized. Many customers like the fact that the wrenches do their job reliably. In our practical test, we were able to confirm that the wrenches are generally very easy to use and do their job reliably, but that there is room for improvement in terms of quality.
For equivalent products, prices are quoted on the Internet from up to € 33 required. Very inexpensive products are already available from € 10. Allen set from Asaki is currently at a price of 15,16 € thus between lower and middle price segment. For the quality and scope of services you get, that is reasonable price ratio.
Gesamtergebnis
weighting | Points scored* | |
---|---|---|
1. Packaging & Labels | 15% | 72 points |
2. Package Contents & Instructions | 15% | 78 points |
3. Product Processing & Appearance | 20% | 93 points |
4. In the practical test | 30% | 96 points |
5. Price/Performance & Consumer Ratings | 20% | 80 points |
Total | 86 points |
The Allen set of the brand asaki therefore receives one from us Overall score of 1,7 and has thus been successfully certified for our test seal. The test was Test period 10/22 carried out and entered into our database under the license number 220903002 guided. You can find more information about our testing procedure at www.prüfengel.de/test procedure.
Test result:
1,7